Youngblood v. Wall
1991 Tenn. App. LEXIS 122, 815 S.W.2d 512 (1991)
Premium Feature
Subscribe to Lexplug to listen to the Case Podcast.
Rule of Law:
Under the doctrine of respondeat superior, a real estate broker is liable for the fraudulent misrepresentations made by their affiliate broker within the scope of employment, particularly when the broker retains the right to control the affiliate's work, establishing an employer-employee relationship.
Facts:
- Robert and Patricia Youngblood entered into a contract to purchase a house on Central Valley Road, represented by Billie Greenberg, an affiliate broker for Snow and Wall Realtors, owned by Howard and Sally Wall.
- The purchase was contingent on the sale of the Youngbloods' current home, the 'O'Brien house'.
- The Youngbloods had a poor credit rating and had not filed income tax returns for 1985 and 1986, which obstructed their ability to obtain permanent financing.
- Greenberg assisted Mr. Youngblood in preparing fraudulent tax returns using figures from someone else's returns to present to lenders.
- Despite knowing that multiple lenders had rejected the Youngbloods' loan applications, Greenberg withheld this information and repeatedly assured them that permanent financing was only weeks away.
- Relying on Greenberg's assurances, the Youngbloods sold their O'Brien house, moved into the Central Valley house, and secured a 90-day 'bridge' loan co-signed by the Walls.
- The Youngbloods were unable to secure permanent financing before the bridge loan came due.
- The Walls paid the bridge loan and subsequently foreclosed on the Central Valley property, resulting in the Youngbloods losing their home and the equity from their previous property.
Procedural Posture:
- Robert and Patricia Youngblood filed an action in Chancery Court (the trial court) against Billie Greenberg and Howard and Sally Wall, d/b/a Snow and Wall Realtors.
- The trial court found that Greenberg made material misrepresentations that caused the Youngbloods to suffer a loss.
- The trial court entered a judgment against Greenberg for $3,690.00 but found the Walls 'blameless of any wrongdoing' and dismissed the claims against them.
- The Youngbloods, as plaintiffs-appellants, appealed the final decree to the Court of Appeals of Tennessee.
Premium Content
Subscribe to Lexplug to view the complete brief
You're viewing a preview with Rule of Law, Facts, and Procedural Posture
Issue:
Is a real estate broker liable for the fraudulent misrepresentations of its affiliate broker under the doctrine of respondeat superior, even if the broker had no knowledge of the misconduct?
Opinions:
Majority - Lewis, J.
Yes. A real estate broker is liable for an affiliate broker's misrepresentations because the relationship is one of employer-employee, making the doctrine of respondeat superior applicable. The court determined that Greenberg was an employee of the Walls, not an independent contractor, based on several factors, most critically the Walls' right to control Greenberg's work. The Walls continually checked on her progress, participated in financing discussions, persuaded other parties in the transaction, and directed her not to speak with the Youngbloods after the foreclosure. Because Greenberg's fraudulent actions were committed within the scope of her employment, the Walls are liable for the resulting harm to the Youngbloods, regardless of their lack of direct knowledge of the fraud.
Analysis:
This decision solidifies the application of respondeat superior to the real estate industry in Tennessee, holding brokerage firms accountable for the misconduct of their affiliated agents. It emphasizes that the broker's 'right of control' over an agent is the dispositive factor in establishing an employer-employee relationship, rather than an independent contractor relationship. The ruling makes it difficult for brokers to insulate themselves from liability for their agents' fraud, thus providing greater protection for consumers in real estate transactions. Future cases will likely focus heavily on the specific evidence of control a broker exercises over its agents.
