Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Co. v. Matlock
60 Cal. App. 4th 583 (1997)
Premium Feature
Subscribe to Lexplug to listen to the Case Podcast.
Rule of Law:
Liability for negligence requires that the resulting harm be a reasonably foreseeable consequence of the defendant's act. A statutory violation only constitutes negligence per se when the harm that occurs is the specific type of harm the statute was designed to prevent.
Facts:
- Timothy Matlock, age 17, bought two packs of cigarettes and gave one to his friend, Eric Erdley, age 15.
- Matlock and Erdley trespassed onto a private storage facility where hundreds of telephone poles were stacked.
- While Erdley was smoking, Matlock began teasing two younger boys who were also on the poles, causing them to run.
- One of the running boys collided with Erdley, causing him to drop his lit cigarette into an inaccessible space between the logs.
- Erdley attempted to retrieve and extinguish the cigarette for about 20 seconds but was unsuccessful.
- Approximately 20 minutes later, Matlock and Erdley observed a fire at the base of the logs.
- The fire caused considerable property damage to the Woodman Pole Company.
Procedural Posture:
- Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Company, as insurer for Eric Erdley, paid claims for the fire damage.
- Wawanesa, as subrogee, filed a suit for contribution against Timothy Matlock and his father, Paul Matlock, in a California trial court.
- Following a bench trial, the trial court found in favor of Wawanesa and awarded it $44,500.
- Timothy Matlock and Paul Matlock (appellants) appealed the trial court's judgment to the California Court of Appeal.
Premium Content
Subscribe to Lexplug to view the complete brief
You're viewing a preview with Rule of Law, Facts, and Procedural Posture
Issue:
Does a minor's act of illegally providing a cigarette to another minor create tort liability for a subsequent fire caused by the second minor accidentally dropping the cigarette, under theories of negligence per se, ordinary negligence, or conspiracy?
Opinions:
Majority - Sills, P. J.
No. Timothy Matlock is not liable because the fire was not a reasonably foreseeable consequence of his actions, and the statute he violated was not intended to prevent fires. For negligence per se, the court reasoned that Penal Code section 308, which prohibits furnishing tobacco to minors, is a health statute designed to prevent addiction, not a fire suppression measure. Therefore, the harm that occurred—a fire—was not the type of harm the statute was designed to prevent. Under ordinary negligence principles, the court found the chain of causation between Matlock giving Erdley a cigarette and the fire was 'too attenuated' and 'fortuitous.' Citing Palsgraf, the court stated 'The risk reasonably to be perceived defines the duty to be obeyed,' and a fire resulting from a series of events including teasing other children and an accidental collision was not within the foreseeable scope of risk of giving a minor a cigarette. Finally, the court dismissed theories of conspiracy and joint venture because there was no evidence of a shared intent or agreement to start a fire; the fire was not a natural and probable consequence of their trespass.
Analysis:
This decision strongly reinforces the foundational tort principles of proximate cause and foreseeability, serving as a modern illustration of the doctrine established in Palsgraf v. Long Island R.R. Co. The court's analysis emphasizes that a simple 'but-for' causal link is insufficient for liability; the harm must be within the scope of risk created by the defendant's conduct. Furthermore, it clarifies the application of negligence per se, limiting its use to cases where the harm suffered directly corresponds to the specific risk the violated statute aimed to mitigate. This case curtails the potential for expansive liability based on a long and improbable chain of events stemming from a minor statutory infraction.
Gunnerbot
AI-powered case assistant
Loaded: Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Co. v. Matlock (1997)
Try: "What was the holding?" or "Explain the dissent"