United States v. Justin Evans
476 F.3d 1176, 2007 WL 218731 (2007)
Premium Feature
Subscribe to Lexplug to listen to the Case Podcast.
Rule of Law:
The Commerce Clause permits Congress to regulate purely intrastate criminal activity if that activity is part of an economic class of activities that in the aggregate substantially affects interstate commerce, or if it involves the use of an instrumentality of interstate commerce, such as a telephone.
Facts:
- From December 2004 to May 2005, Justin Evans employed a fourteen-year-old girl, 'Jane Doe', as a prostitute in Miami-Dade County, Florida.
- Evans arranged for Jane Doe to meet clients at local hotels and collected the money she earned.
- Evans communicated with Jane Doe and her customers using both a cellular telephone and a land-line telephone to arrange and monitor her activities.
- Evans supplied Jane Doe with condoms of the brand Lifestyle, which are manufactured overseas, imported into Georgia, and distributed throughout the United States.
- In February 2005, Jane Doe was hospitalized and diagnosed with AIDS.
- Shortly after her release from the hospital, Evans called Jane Doe and induced her to resume working for him as a prostitute.
- All of Evans's criminal activities related to Jane Doe occurred solely within the state of Florida.
Procedural Posture:
- A federal grand jury indicted Justin Evans for violating 18 U.S.C. § 1591(a)(1) and § 2422(b).
- Evans filed a motion in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida to dismiss the indictment, arguing the facts did not satisfy the statutes' interstate-commerce elements.
- Evans entered a conditional guilty plea, reserving his right to appeal the court's ruling on his motion to dismiss.
- The district court denied Evans's motion to dismiss the indictment.
- Evans (appellant) appealed the district court's denial to the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, where the United States was the appellee.
Premium Content
Subscribe to Lexplug to view the complete brief
You're viewing a preview with Rule of Law, Facts, and Procedural Posture
Issue:
Does the Commerce Clause permit federal prosecution under 18 U.S.C. §§ 1591(a)(1) and 2422(b) for purely intrastate child prostitution activities based on an aggregate effect on commerce and the use of instrumentalities of commerce?
Opinions:
Majority - Bowman, Circuit Judge
Yes, the Commerce Clause permits federal prosecution for these intrastate activities. The court held that purely local activities can be regulated by Congress when they are part of a broader economic 'class of activities' that, in the aggregate, has a substantial effect on interstate commerce. The court reasoned that § 1591 is part of the Trafficking Victims Protection Act, a comprehensive scheme to regulate the national and international market of human trafficking. Citing Gonzales v. Raich, the court found that Congress had a rational basis to conclude that local instances of sex trafficking, when aggregated, frustrate its ability to regulate the interstate market. Furthermore, the court held that the use of a telephone—an instrumentality of interstate commerce—is sufficient on its own to establish federal jurisdiction under § 2422(b), even if the calls themselves are purely intrastate.
Analysis:
This decision reaffirms the broad scope of congressional power under the Commerce Clause, particularly following the Supreme Court's reasoning in Gonzales v. Raich. It solidifies the principle that federal statutes can reach purely local criminal conduct if that conduct is part of a national economic market that Congress seeks to regulate comprehensively, such as human trafficking. The case also provides a clear jurisdictional hook for prosecutors by confirming that any use of an instrumentality of interstate commerce, like a telephone, satisfies the jurisdictional element for relevant statutes, removing the need to prove that a specific communication crossed state lines. This strengthens the federal government's ability to prosecute local crimes that have a connection, however attenuated, to interstate commerce.
