Portland General Electric Company v. Bureau of Labor and Industries
859 P.2d 1143 (1993)
Premium Feature
Subscribe to Lexplug to listen to the Case Podcast.
Rule of Law:
Under Oregon's Parental Leave Law, an employee is statutorily entitled to use any accrued sick leave during parental leave, and this right is not conditioned by conflicting eligibility requirements in a collective bargaining agreement, such as a requirement that the employee be physically ill.
Facts:
- An employee of Portland General Electric Company (PGE) was a member of the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers (IBEW).
- The collective bargaining agreement between PGE and IBEW provided that paid sick leave was only to be used when an employee was actually sick or injured, or for routine medical or dental exams.
- In March 1988, following the birth of his child, the employee requested a 12-week parental leave.
- As part of his leave request, the employee sought to use over nine weeks of his accrued paid sick leave to remain in paid status.
- PGE denied the employee's request to use the accrued sick leave for parental leave, citing the terms of the collective bargaining agreement.
Procedural Posture:
- The employee filed a complaint against Portland General Electric Company (PGE) with the Bureau of Labor and Industries (BOLI), an administrative agency.
- After a hearing, BOLI, acting as the court of first instance, ruled in favor of the employee.
- PGE, as petitioner, sought judicial review of BOLI's final order in the Oregon Court of Appeals, an intermediate appellate court.
- The Court of Appeals, sitting in banc, affirmed BOLI's order in a 5-4 decision.
- PGE, as petitioner, sought review from the Supreme Court of Oregon.
Premium Content
Subscribe to Lexplug to view the complete brief
You're viewing a preview with Rule of Law, Facts, and Procedural Posture
Issue:
Does Oregon's Parental Leave Law, ORS 659.360(3), permit an employee to use accrued paid sick leave during parental leave even if the employee does not meet the conditions for using such leave as defined in a collective bargaining agreement?
Opinions:
Majority - Van Hoomissen, J.
Yes, ORS 659.360(3) permits an employee to use accrued paid sick leave during parental leave regardless of conflicting terms in a collective bargaining agreement. The statute unambiguously states that an employee 'shall be entitled to utilize any accrued... sick leave... during the parental leave.' The court reasoned that the text itself provides only one precondition: the leave must have 'accrued.' The legislature deliberately omitted any reference to collective bargaining agreements in the sentence granting this right to employees, while explicitly including such a reference in the following sentence that grants rights to employers. This purposeful omission indicates that the employee's right to use accrued leave is absolute and not subject to contractual limitations.
Analysis:
This case solidifies the principle that statutory employment rights supersede conflicting terms in private contracts like collective bargaining agreements. It also formally establishes the hierarchical 'text, context, and legislative history' methodology for statutory interpretation in Oregon, prioritizing the plain meaning of a statute's text above all else. This framework has become a cornerstone of Oregon jurisprudence. The decision provides a significant protection for employees, ensuring they can use earned benefits to make parental leave financially feasible, thereby giving full effect to the legislative intent behind the Parental Leave Law.
Unlock the full brief for Portland General Electric Company v. Bureau of Labor and Industries