Marina Point, Ltd. v. Wolfson
496 P.2d 115 (1982), 496 P.2d 114 (1972) (1972)
Premium Feature
Subscribe to Lexplug to listen to the Case Podcast.
Rule of Law:
The employer-employee relationship, a jurisdictional prerequisite for a workers' compensation claim, terminates when the employment contract ends. An injury sustained by a former employee after termination, while on the employer's premises solely for the personal benefit of retrieving property, does not arise out of and in the course of employment.
Facts:
- Lloyd E. Parten was employed by M. & P. International, Inc. as a shop foreman.
- As a condition of his employment, Parten was required to furnish his own tools and shop manuals, which he kept at the employer's shop.
- At noon on a Saturday, M. & P. International's president, Mr. Pankhurst, gave Parten his final paycheck and informed him his employment was terminated effective immediately.
- Because Parten's tool chest was very heavy and other employees had left, Pankhurst agreed to meet Parten at the shop the following day, Sunday, to help him load his belongings.
- Around noon on Sunday, approximately 24 hours after his termination, Parten slipped and injured his back while loading his shop manuals into his pickup truck on the company's property.
- Parten was not being paid for his time, and he acknowledged that Pankhurst was helping him as a personal favor.
Procedural Posture:
- Lloyd E. Parten filed a claim for workers' compensation benefits against M. & P. International, Inc. in the State Industrial Court.
- A trial judge of the State Industrial Court found the injury compensable and entered an order awarding benefits to Parten.
- The employer, M. & P. International, Inc., and its insurance carrier appealed the trial judge's order to the State Industrial Court sitting en banc.
- The State Industrial Court en banc vacated the trial judge's order and denied the claim.
- Parten (petitioner) sought review of the en banc court's order in the Supreme Court of Oklahoma.
Premium Content
Subscribe to Lexplug to view the complete brief
You're viewing a preview with Rule of Law, Facts, and Procedural Posture
Issue:
Does an accidental injury arise out of and in the course of employment for workers' compensation purposes when it occurs after the employment contract has been unequivocally terminated, while the former employee is on the employer's premises for the sole purpose of retrieving his personal tools?
Opinions:
Majority - Lavender, J.
No. An accidental injury does not arise out of and in the course of employment when it occurs after the employment contract has been terminated and the individual is on the premises solely for personal reasons, such as retrieving property. The court reasoned that the existence of an employer-employee relationship at the time of injury is a fundamental prerequisite for the State Industrial Court's jurisdiction. This relationship is contractual and ceases upon termination. Parten's employment was unequivocally terminated at noon on Saturday. The act of retrieving his tools on Sunday, though a practical necessity for him, was for his own benefit and on his own time, not a continuation of his employment duties. The court rejected the argument that a requirement to furnish tools as part of the job implies a contractual duty to remove them, holding that such an act does not extend the employment contract beyond its termination.
Analysis:
This decision establishes a clear temporal boundary for the employer-employee relationship in workers' compensation cases. It holds that once an employment contract is definitively terminated, the relationship ceases for compensation purposes. The ruling distinguishes acts that are integral to employment from post-termination personal errands, even if they occur on the employer's premises. This provides a bright-line rule that limits employer liability, preventing the indefinite extension of the employment period for tasks like retrieving personal belongings. Future cases may need to analyze whether an act is a final duty of employment versus a purely personal task post-termination.
