La Belle Epoque, LLC v. Old Europe Antique Manor, LLC
2008 Md. LEXIS 520, 406 Md. 194, 958 A.2d 269 (2008)
Premium Feature
Subscribe to Lexplug to listen to the Case Podcast.
Rule of Law:
A landlord who accepts rent from a new occupant with knowledge of an intended but formally defective lease assignment may be found to have waived a lease's anti-assignment clause and be estopped from asserting the Statute of Frauds, thereby creating a genuine issue of material fact as to the occupant's status as a tenant.
Facts:
- On July 23, 2001, Double H Family, LLC leased a commercial space to Francois Desbois for a five-year term. The lease required the landlord's written consent for any assignment.
- Isabelle Sanchez-Tintenier, who helped Desbois negotiate the lease, was principally responsible for the operation of Desbois's business as he lived in France.
- In July or August 2002, Desbois discontinued his business, and Sanchez-Tintenier took over the premises, paying Desbois approximately $10,000 and starting her own business, Old Europe Manor, LLC.
- Sanchez-Tintenier informed Double H Family's property manager, David Dant, that she was taking over the store, and he allegedly told her it was 'no problem' and 'fine'.
- For the next 17 months, Sanchez-Tintenier paid the monthly rent using checks from her business, Old Europe Antique Manor LLC, which Double H Family's agent accepted and deposited.
- La Belle Epoque, LLC, the tenant in the upstairs space of the same building, allegedly created a large pile of debris in an adjacent common area.
- In February 2003, a major winter storm occurred, and runoff water, allegedly trapped by the debris pile, infiltrated and flooded Old Europe's premises, causing significant damage to its inventory.
Procedural Posture:
- Old Europe Manor, LLC filed a complaint against Double H Family, LLC and La Belle Epoque, LLC in the Circuit Court for Montgomery County (a trial court).
- Double H Family and La Belle Epoque both filed motions for summary judgment.
- The Circuit Court granted summary judgment in favor of both defendants on all counts, holding that Old Europe was not a tenant but a trespasser or bare licensee.
- Old Europe (as appellant) filed a timely appeal to the Court of Special Appeals of Maryland (an intermediate appellate court).
- The Court of Special Appeals vacated the Circuit Court’s judgment, finding there were material disputes of fact as to whether Old Europe became a periodic tenant by operation of law.
- Double H Family and La Belle Epoque (as petitioners) petitioned for a writ of certiorari, which the Court of Appeals of Maryland (the state's highest court) granted.
Premium Content
Subscribe to Lexplug to view the complete brief
You're viewing a preview with Rule of Law, Facts, and Procedural Posture
Issue:
Does a landlord's acceptance of rent from a new occupant, with knowledge of an intended but formally defective lease assignment, create a genuine issue of material fact as to whether a tenancy was created by operation of law, precluding summary judgment?
Opinions:
Majority - Greene, J.
Yes. A landlord's acceptance of rent from a new occupant, with knowledge of an intended but formally defective lease assignment, creates a genuine issue of material fact as to whether a tenancy was created by operation of law, which precludes summary judgment. Although the oral assignment from Desbois to Old Europe did not comply with the written lease's requirement for written consent or the Statute of Frauds, a landlord's conduct can waive these requirements. A waiver occurs when a party intentionally relinquishes a known right, and under Maryland law, a lessor who accepts rent from a new entity with knowledge of an assignment may waive the ability to contest it. Sanchez-Tintenier's testimony that she informed the landlord's agent she was 'taking over,' combined with Double H Family's subsequent acceptance of rent checks from 'Old Europe,' creates a factual dispute about the landlord's knowledge and intent. This conduct could establish an assignment by 'operation of law,' an exception to the Statute of Frauds based on estoppel. Because a reasonable jury could find that Double H Family waived its rights and accepted Old Europe as a tenant, the determination of Old Europe's legal status is a disputed material fact that makes summary judgment improper.
Analysis:
This decision reinforces the principle that a party's conduct can override formal contractual requirements, such as anti-assignment clauses and the Statute of Frauds. It serves as a caution to landlords that they cannot knowingly accept the benefits of a tenancy, such as rent payments from a new occupant, and then later disclaim any landlord-tenant relationship to avoid liability. By holding that waiver and estoppel are questions of fact for a jury, the court makes it more difficult for landlords to dispose of such cases on summary judgment. The ruling emphasizes that the parties' intent, as inferred from their actions, is a key inquiry in determining legal relationships in property law.
