Jerry McCrary v. Dennis Shaw, John Mills, and Edward Courtney
1993 U.S. App. LEXIS 10355, 37 Fed. R. Serv. 1323, 992 F.2d 809 (1993)
Premium Feature
Subscribe to Lexplug to listen to the Case Podcast.
Rule of Law:
An inmate's prior conduct violation reports and reputation for violence are relevant and admissible in an excessive force claim to determine the objective reasonableness of the force used by correctional officers and to show the officers' subjective state of mind.
Facts:
- Jerry McCrary-El was an inmate housed in the administrative segregation wing of the Farmington Correctional Center (FCC), designated for dangerous and violent inmates.
- Correctional officers attempted to place a new cellmate into McCrary-El's one-man cell.
- McCrary-El refused to comply with the officers' verbal commands to move to the back of the cell to allow the new inmate to enter.
- An altercation occurred between McCrary-El and several officers inside the cell.
- McCrary-El alleged that the officers grabbed him, slammed him onto the concrete floor, punched him, and put him in a headlock, causing injury.
- The officers contended that McCrary-El shoved an officer as soon as the cell door opened, requiring them to enter and restrain him using established procedures.
- The FCC videotaped this first cell movement, but the tape was not produced at trial.
- A few hours later, officers moved McCrary-El again, and this second movement was videotaped and shown to the jury.
Procedural Posture:
- Jerry McCrary-El sued several correctional officers in the U.S. District Court, alleging use of excessive force in violation of 42 U.S.C. § 1983.
- The district court granted the officers' motion to dismiss McCrary-El's claim regarding a second cell movement.
- The case proceeded to a three-day jury trial on the claim of excessive force during the first cell movement.
- The jury returned a verdict in favor of the defendant officers.
- McCrary-El filed a motion for a new trial, which the district court denied.
- McCrary-El, as appellant, appealed the judgment to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit.
Premium Content
Subscribe to Lexplug to view the complete brief
You're viewing a preview with Rule of Law, Facts, and Procedural Posture
Issue:
Did the trial court abuse its discretion by admitting an inmate's prior conduct violation reports as evidence in an excessive force claim, where the reports were used to show the reasonableness of the officers' actions and their state of mind?
Opinions:
Majority - Morris Sheppard Arnold
No, the trial court did not abuse its discretion by admitting the inmate's prior conduct reports. The question of whether force is excessive cannot be assessed in a vacuum and must account for the specific circumstances, including the known risks posed by an inmate. The officers' awareness of McCrary-El's reputation for violence was relevant both to their subjective state of mind and to the objective reasonableness of the force used. Because McCrary-El sought punitive damages, which requires showing 'evil motive or intent,' the evidence was highly probative of the defendants' motives. The court concluded that the trial judge acted within his discretion in determining that the probative value of this evidence was not substantially outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice under Federal Rule of Evidence 403.
Analysis:
This decision solidifies the principle that an officer's knowledge of an inmate's violent history is a crucial part of the 'totality of the circumstances' when evaluating the reasonableness of force under the Eighth Amendment. It allows defendants in such cases to introduce evidence of the plaintiff's character for violence to contextualize their actions and justify the level of force used. This ruling emphasizes that the reasonableness standard is not abstract but is tailored to the specific, known dangers faced by officers, potentially making it more difficult for inmates with violent records to succeed in excessive force lawsuits.
Unlock the full brief for Jerry McCrary v. Dennis Shaw, John Mills, and Edward Courtney