Jackson v. State
286 Md. 430, 1979 Md. LEXIS 305, 408 A.2d 711 (1979)
Premium Feature
Subscribe to Lexplug to listen to the Case Podcast.
Rule of Law:
A felon is liable for first-degree murder under the felony-murder rule when their commission of a felony foreseeably creates a life-threatening situation that results in a death, even if the lethal act is performed by a third party, such as a police officer, attempting to apprehend the felon.
Facts:
- William Henry Jackson and James Wells, Jr. robbed a jewelry shop owned by Bernard Sugar and Charlotte Farber, brandishing handguns.
- When police arrived, Jackson and Wells were unable to escape.
- Jackson grabbed Sugar and Wells grabbed Farber, using them as human shields while holding them at gunpoint.
- The robbers forced the hostages into a police car and initiated a high-speed chase, during which they switched vehicles and continued to hold the hostages in positions of danger.
- The chase ended when police established a roadblock, bringing the felons' car to a halt.
- Officer Wayne White ran to the car, jumped on its hood, and swung his shotgun at Wells's arm in an attempt to disarm him.
- During this action, Officer White's shotgun accidentally discharged, firing pellets that struck and killed Bernard Sugar, who was lying on the front seat.
Procedural Posture:
- William Henry Jackson and James Wells, Jr. were indicted for the murder of Bernard Sugar.
- In the Circuit Court for Worcester County (trial court), both defendants pleaded guilty to murder in the first degree pursuant to a plea agreement.
- The trial court accepted their pleas, found them guilty, and sentenced each to life imprisonment.
- Jackson and Wells (appellants) appealed to the Court of Special Appeals of Maryland (intermediate appellate court), arguing their guilty pleas lacked a factual basis because they did not fire the fatal shot.
- The Court of Special Appeals affirmed the judgments of the trial court.
- The Court of Appeals of Maryland (the state's highest court) granted the defendants' petition for a writ of certiorari to decide the issue.
Premium Content
Subscribe to Lexplug to view the complete brief
You're viewing a preview with Rule of Law, Facts, and Procedural Posture
Issue:
Does the accidental killing of a hostage by a police officer during the apprehension of felons constitute first-degree murder on the part of the felons under the Maryland felony-murder statute?
Opinions:
Majority - Orth, J.
Yes. The accidental killing of a hostage by a police officer during the apprehension of felons constitutes first-degree murder by the felons when their actions created the dangerous situation that led to the death. The court reasoned that criminal liability for murder hinges on a causal relationship between the defendant's act and the resulting harm. By kidnapping Bernard Sugar and using him as a human shield during a dangerous police chase, Jackson and Wells created a foreseeable zone of peril. Their actions were the 'but for' cause of Sugar's death, and the officer's accidental shot was a direct and foreseeable response to the felons' conduct, not a superseding cause that would break the chain of causation. Relying on precedents like Taylor v. State and Wilson v. State, the court adopted a proximate cause theory, holding that the felons were just as much the cause of Sugar's death as if they had fired the fatal shot themselves because they forced the victim into a known place of danger.
Analysis:
This decision solidifies the proximate cause theory of felony murder in Maryland, particularly in 'human shield' scenarios. It explicitly rejects a narrower 'agency' theory, which would require the fatal act to be performed by one of the felons or their accomplices. The ruling expands criminal liability for felons, making them responsible for the foreseeable and responsive actions of third parties, like law enforcement, that result from their dangerous criminal conduct. This precedent establishes that creating a zone of extreme danger during a felony is sufficient to establish the causal link for murder if that danger foreseeably results in a death.
