In Re Marriage of Minix
280 Ill. Dec. 256, 344 Ill. App. 3d 801, 801 N.E.2d 1201 (2003)
Premium Feature
Subscribe to Lexplug to listen to the Case Podcast.
Rule of Law:
A court may not restrict a non-custodial parent's right to expose their child to their religious beliefs during visitation unless the custodial parent makes a clear, affirmative showing that such exposure poses a substantial threat of harm to the child's physical, mental, or emotional well-being.
Facts:
- Wendy Sue Dunaven-Minix and David Wayne Minix divorced, with Wendy receiving custody of their minor child, Nicole.
- Wendy was a member of the Unity Church and wanted to raise Nicole in that faith.
- David practiced a different Christian denomination, described as 'close to Pentecostal'.
- During his court-ordered weekend visitations, David had been taking Nicole to his church services for approximately three years.
- Wendy told David that Nicole was getting 'confused' by attending both churches and asked him to stop.
- Wendy did not present any evidence of specific doctrinal differences between the two churches or any evidence of physical or emotional harm to Nicole beyond the general assertion of confusion.
Procedural Posture:
- The circuit court of Macon County entered a judgment dissolving the marriage of Wendy Sue Dunaven-Minix and David Wayne Minix.
- Wendy (the custodial parent) filed a 'Motion to Modify and Limit Visitation' in the trial court, asking the court to order David to refrain from taking their child to his church.
- After a hearing, the trial court denied Wendy's motion, finding she had failed to show any substantial threat to the child.
- Wendy filed a motion to reconsider, which the trial court also denied.
- Wendy (appellant) appealed the trial court's orders to the Illinois Appellate Court, with David (appellee) as the responding party.
Premium Content
Subscribe to Lexplug to view the complete brief
You're viewing a preview with Rule of Law, Facts, and Procedural Posture
Issue:
Does a custodial parent's statutory right to determine a child's religious upbringing permit a court to prohibit the non-custodial parent from taking the child to their church during visitation, absent an affirmative showing that doing so would harm the child?
Opinions:
Majority - Justice Appleton
No. A custodial parent's statutory right to determine a child's religious upbringing does not permit a court to prohibit the non-custodial parent from taking the child to their church without an affirmative showing that it would harm the child. The court must balance the custodial parent's statutory right to direct religious training (Section 608(a)) against the non-custodial parent's right to unrestricted visitation (Section 607(c)) and freedom of religion. Adopting the majority rule from other jurisdictions and citing the Supreme Court's standard in Wisconsin v. Yoder, the court held that any restriction on a parent's religious expression with their child requires a 'clear, affirmative showing' of a 'substantial threat' of harm. Because Wendy failed to provide any evidence of such harm, presenting only a vague claim of 'confusion,' the trial court's refusal to restrict David's visitation was not an abuse of discretion.
Analysis:
This decision aligns Illinois with the majority of American jurisdictions by establishing a harm-based standard for resolving disputes over a child's religious upbringing between divorced parents. It clarifies that a custodial parent's statutory right to determine religious training is not absolute and does not permit them to veto the non-custodial parent's religious expression during visitation. The ruling raises the evidentiary bar for the parent seeking the restriction, requiring them to prove actual or threatened harm to the child rather than relying on mere disagreement with the other parent's faith or general claims of confusion. This precedent prioritizes the child's best interests, defined by the absence of demonstrable harm, while protecting the non-custodial parent's right to a meaningful relationship that includes sharing their religious beliefs.
