In re Estate of Kurrelmeyer
*361-*370 (2006)
Premium Feature
Subscribe to Lexplug to listen to the Case Podcast.
Rule of Law:
A durable general power of attorney that expressly grants an agent the authority to "execute...trust instruments" empowers that agent to create a new trust on the principal's behalf, though the agent's actions remain subject to their fiduciary duty of loyalty.
Facts:
- In 1980, Louis Kurrelmeyer executed a will that granted his wife, Martina Kurrelmeyer, a life estate in a property known as "Clearwater," with the remainder interest passing to his surviving children.
- In 1996, Louis Kurrelmeyer, while competent, executed a durable general power of attorney, appointing Martina as his attorney-in-fact.
- The power of attorney granted Martina the explicit authority to "execute and deliver any...trust instruments."
- In December 2000, after Louis Kurrelmeyer had become incompetent, Martina used her authority under the power of attorney to create the "Louis H. Kurrelmeyer Living Trust."
- Days later, Martina transferred title of the Clearwater property from her husband's name into the newly created trust.
- The terms of the trust provided Martina with more expansive rights to the Clearwater property than the will, allowing the trust to pay for expenses and permitting her to request a sale of the home for her benefit.
Procedural Posture:
- During the administration of Louis Kurrelmeyer's estate, his son, Louis Kurrelmeyer Jr., objected in probate court to the exclusion of the Clearwater property from the estate inventory, challenging the validity of the trust.
- The probate court upheld the trust.
- The children appealed the probate court's decision to the Chittenden Superior Court (an intermediate appellate court).
- On cross-motions for summary judgment, the superior court granted judgment for the children, concluding the power of attorney did not authorize the creation of a trust and reversing the probate court.
- Martina Kurrelmeyer, as appellant, appealed the superior court's decision to the Supreme Court of Vermont.
Premium Content
Subscribe to Lexplug to view the complete brief
You're viewing a preview with Rule of Law, Facts, and Procedural Posture
Issue:
Does a durable general power of attorney that grants the agent the authority to "execute and deliver...trust instruments" authorize the agent to create a new revocable inter vivos trust on behalf of the principal?
Opinions:
Majority - Burgess, D.J.
Yes. A durable power of attorney that grants an agent the power to 'execute...trust instruments' provides the authority to create a new trust on the principal's behalf. The court rejected a rule of strict construction for powers of attorney, instead adopting a standard that seeks to determine the principal’s intent by examining the express terms and the overall context of the instrument. The specific language authorizing the execution of 'trust instruments,' granted 'in addition' to the power to add assets to existing trusts, unambiguously demonstrated the principal's intent to grant the power to create a new trust. While creating a trust is a significant act, it is not a non-delegable personal duty like executing a will and it serves legitimate estate planning purposes. The court remanded the separate question of whether this specific act constituted self-dealing or a breach of the agent's fiduciary duty of loyalty.
Analysis:
This decision establishes that Vermont courts will interpret the scope of a power of attorney based on the principal's expressed intent rather than a default rule of strict construction. It confirms that the power to create a trust can be delegated to an agent if the instrument's language is sufficiently clear, such as granting the power to "execute trust instruments." Critically, the ruling bifurcates the analysis of an agent's actions into two distinct inquiries: 1) whether the agent had the authority to act, and 2) whether the authorized act was a breach of the agent's fiduciary duty of loyalty. This creates a clear, two-step framework for future cases challenging an agent's estate planning decisions.
Unlock the full brief for In re Estate of Kurrelmeyer