Illi, Inc. v. Margolis
267 Md. 30, 1972 Md. LEXIS 654, 296 A.2d 412 (1972)
Premium Feature
Subscribe to Lexplug to listen to the Case Podcast.
Rule of Law:
A judgment creditor's inchoate lien on personal property, which arises upon delivery of a writ of fieri facias to a sheriff, is perfected by a levy before the writ's return date; however, this lien is extinguished if the writ is returned nulla bona. A perfected lien is not considered abandoned merely by a good faith delay in the execution sale to allow the debtor to make installment payments.
Facts:
- Brookfield Furniture Co. and Youngs, Inc. each obtained judgments against Stan Martin, Limited.
- In the spring of 1970, Brookfield and Youngs had writs of fieri facias (fi fa) issued, and a sheriff levied on Stan Martin's property.
- Brookfield and Youngs agreed to postpone the sale of the levied goods after Stan Martin's president offered to make weekly payments of $50 to each while seeking refinancing.
- Stan Martin made several weekly payments, reducing each debt by $700, before the payments ceased due to failed refinancing efforts.
- Five other creditors, including lili, Inc. and Rucker Industries, Inc., also obtained judgments against Stan Martin.
- On November 2, 1970, these five creditors had writs of fi fa delivered to a constable.
- On November 4, 1970, before any levy was made under the five new writs, Stan Martin transferred all its assets to a trustee, Aaron Margolis, for the benefit of all creditors.
- After learning of the assignment, counsel for the five creditors instructed the constable to return the writs, believing a levy was no longer possible.
Procedural Posture:
- Seven judgment creditors filed petitions in an equity proceeding in the Circuit Court of Baltimore City, seeking priority of payment from the assets of Stan Martin, Limited, held by trustee Aaron Margolis.
- The court referred the matter of priority to a master in chancery.
- The master recommended denying priority status to all seven petitioners.
- The creditors filed exceptions to the master's report.
- The Circuit Court of Baltimore City overruled the exceptions and adopted the master's report, denying priority to all petitioners.
- The seven judgment creditors appealed the Circuit Court's order to the Court of Appeals of Maryland.
Premium Content
Subscribe to Lexplug to view the complete brief
You're viewing a preview with Rule of Law, Facts, and Procedural Posture
Issue:
Does a judgment creditor obtain a priority lien on a debtor's personal property that survives an assignment for the benefit of creditors when either (1) the creditor's writ of fieri facias is returned nulla bona without a levy, or (2) after a levy is made, the creditor agrees to delay the sale and accept installment payments from the debtor?
Opinions:
Majority - Digges, J.
As to the first group of creditors, no; as to the second group, yes. A judgment creditor does not obtain a priority lien when the writ is returned nulla bona without a levy, but a creditor who makes a valid levy maintains their priority lien even if they agree in good faith to delay the sale. For the five creditors whose writs were returned nulla bona, their inchoate liens were extinguished. An inchoate lien on personal property is created upon delivery of a writ of fi fa to the sheriff, but it only becomes a consummate lien if a levy is made before the writ's return date. The failure to levy meant the lien was never perfected, and the nulla bona return extinguished it, leaving these creditors with no priority. For Brookfield and Youngs, their liens were consummated by the levy. Their subsequent agreement to delay the sale while accepting payments was a good faith effort to collect the debt, not an abuse of the writ or an attempt to hinder other creditors. Distinguishing this from cases where a creditor instructs a sheriff not to levy at all, the court found that this reasonable indulgence did not constitute an abandonment of their perfected liens, and their priority status was preserved.
Analysis:
This case clarifies the essential mechanics of perfecting a judgment lien on personal property in Maryland, emphasizing that a levy is a non-negotiable step to convert an inchoate lien into a consummate one. The decision creates a clear dividing line: a writ returned 'nulla bona' kills the lien and any resulting priority. Furthermore, the ruling provides important guidance on lien abandonment, establishing a good-faith standard that protects creditors who reasonably accommodate debtors with payment plans, thereby encouraging workouts without sacrificing the creditor's priority position.
