First National Bank of Lawrence v. Methodist Home for the Aged
309 P.2d 389, 181 Kan. 100 (1957)
Premium Feature
Subscribe to Lexplug to listen to the Case Podcast.
Rule of Law:
When a contract for life care includes a probationary period and is silent as to the disposition of the life-membership fee upon the applicant's death during that period, the contract is not fully executed, and the fee must be returned to the applicant's estate.
Facts:
- Bertha C. Ellsworth, a woman over 71 years old, applied for admission to the Methodist Home for the Aged.
- On May 10, 1954, Ellsworth was admitted to the Home and signed a contract for lifetime care.
- The contract required a payment of $10,779.60 and stipulated a two-month probationary period, during which either party could terminate the agreement and the payment would be refunded, less a monthly charge.
- The Home's bylaws, incorporated into the contract, also described this as a two-month trial period.
- On June 4, 1954, the fee for a 'Life Membership' was paid on Ellsworth's behalf.
- On June 10, 1954, one month into the probationary period, Ellsworth died.
- At the time of her death, neither Ellsworth nor the Home had made an election to continue or discontinue her stay after the probationary period.
Procedural Posture:
- The administrator of Bertha C. Ellsworth's estate made a written demand on the Methodist Home For the Aged for a refund of the life-membership fee, which was refused.
- The administrator (plaintiff) received authority from the probate court and sued the Home (defendant) in a Kansas trial court to recover the money.
- The trial court overruled the defendant's demurrer to the petition.
- After the defendant filed an answer, the case went to trial.
- The trial court entered judgment for the plaintiff, ordering the defendant to refund the payment less certain specified deductions.
- The defendant (appellant) appealed the trial court's judgment to the Supreme Court of Kansas.
Premium Content
Subscribe to Lexplug to view the complete brief
You're viewing a preview with Rule of Law, Facts, and Procedural Posture
Issue:
Does the death of an applicant to a life-care home during the contractual two-month probationary period prevent the home from retaining the life-membership fee paid by the applicant, when the contract is silent on this contingency?
Opinions:
Majority - Parker, C. J.
Yes, the death of the applicant during the probationary period prevents the home from retaining the fee. The court held that because the contract provided for a two-month probationary or trial period, Bertha C. Ellsworth never attained the status of a life member. The contract was ambiguous because it did not specify what should happen to the life-membership fee if the resident died during this period. Applying rules of contract construction, the court construed the ambiguous language against the defendant Home, as it was the drafter of the instrument. The court reasoned that a reasonable person in Ellsworth's position would have understood that the payment was for a life membership she had not yet secured, and that until she successfully completed the probationary period, her estate would be entitled to a refund. Her death made it impossible to fulfill the condition precedent of completing the trial period, thus the contract for life membership was never fully executed and the consideration for it failed.
Analysis:
This decision establishes a default rule for life-care contracts in Kansas that are silent on the consequences of a resident's death during a probationary period. It underscores the principle of contra proferentem, where contractual ambiguities are construed against the drafter, which is particularly significant in contracts of adhesion where one party has superior bargaining power. This ruling places the burden on institutions like nursing homes to explicitly and clearly state in their contracts if they intend to retain fees when a resident dies during a trial period. The case serves as a precedent for situations where a condition precedent in a contract becomes impossible to fulfill due to an unforeseen event like death.
Unlock the full brief for First National Bank of Lawrence v. Methodist Home for the Aged