Estate of Morrison
98 Cal. App. 2d 380, 220 P.2d 413 (1950)
Premium Feature
Subscribe to Lexplug to listen to the Case Podcast.
Rule of Law:
Multiple writings, connected by sequence of thought and physical proximity, may be treated as a single testamentary instrument under the doctrine of integration if the evidence shows the testator intended them to constitute one will, even if not all writings are individually signed and dated.
Facts:
- Wilton M. Morrison had a formal, typewritten will dated December 6, 1948.
- On April 9, 1949, the day before he died from cancer, Morrison asked his wife for a pencil and a pad of paper to make changes to his will.
- In the presence of his wife and a friend, Lloyd Hanck, Morrison wrote on a sheet of paper, stating 'I mean for all of this to be in my "Will"' and 'it is only to help these people.'
- Morrison signed and dated this sheet, and had his wife and Hanck sign as witnesses.
- While writing, Morrison was observed consulting a second sheet of paper, which contained a list of names and monetary amounts in his handwriting but was not signed or dated.
- Morrison folded both sheets of paper together, placed them in an envelope which he then sealed, and gave it to Hanck.
- Morrison told Hanck to deliver the envelope to the bank, stating it contained 'something for Hanck and the nurse,' both of whom were named on the unsigned list of bequests.
Procedural Posture:
- After Wilton M. Morrison's death, Security Trust and Savings Bank, the executor, filed a petition in the trial court for probate of his formal will.
- The bank also submitted two handwritten documents found in a sealed envelope and asked the court to determine if they constituted a valid holographic codicil.
- The trial court admitted the formal will to probate but found that the handwritten documents did not constitute a valid codicil and denied their admission to probate.
- Ruth Rogers and other beneficiaries named in the handwritten documents appealed the trial court's order to the California Court of Appeals, Fourth District.
- The executor, Security Trust and Savings Bank, is the respondent in the appeal.
Premium Content
Subscribe to Lexplug to view the complete brief
You're viewing a preview with Rule of Law, Facts, and Procedural Posture
Issue:
Do two separate holographic writings, one signed and dated and the other an unsigned and undated list of bequests, constitute a single, valid holographic codicil under the doctrine of integration when they are connected by sequence of thought and placed together in a sealed envelope by the testator?
Opinions:
Majority - Mussell, J.
Yes. The two separate writings constitute a single, valid holographic codicil under the doctrine of integration. The court reasoned that the testator's intent for the two documents to be read as one was clear. The signed document's references to 'all of this' and 'these people' are meaningless without the second, unsigned document which lists the beneficiaries and bequests. This connection through a 'sequence of thought,' combined with the physical integration of the documents (being folded together and sealed in the same envelope), demonstrates the testator's intent to form a single instrument. Citing Estate of Dumas, the court held that the principle of integration applies, which allows for admitting multiple connected writings to probate as one holographic will, rather than requiring each separate document to meet all statutory requirements on its own.
Analysis:
This case reinforces the doctrine of integration in California wills law, prioritizing the testator's intent over strict adherence to statutory formalities for each separate page of a will. The decision clarifies that courts may consider both internal evidence (sequence of thought) and extrinsic evidence (physical connection, testator's statements) to determine if multiple writings form a single testamentary instrument. This provides flexibility in fulfilling a testator's wishes but also underscores the importance for future litigation of demonstrating a clear link between separate testamentary documents.
