Estate of Graegin v. Commissioner
1988 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 485, 56 T.C.M. 387, 1988 T.C. Memo. 477 (1988)
Premium Feature
Subscribe to Lexplug to listen to the Case Podcast.
Rule of Law:
An estate may deduct the full, non-contingent, future balloon payment of interest on a loan as an administration expense under I.R.C. § 2053(a)(2) if the loan was necessarily incurred to pay estate taxes and avoid a forced sale of illiquid assets, and the amount of interest is ascertainable with reasonable certainty and will be paid.
Facts:
- Upon his death on November 13, 1981, Cecil Graegin's estate consisted primarily of illiquid assets, including a controlling interest in Graegin Industries, Inc., a closely-held corporation.
- The estate lacked sufficient liquid assets to pay its federal estate tax liability of $204,218.
- To avoid a forced sale of the company stock, the estate's executors borrowed $204,218 from Graegin Corporation, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Graegin Industries.
- The loan was structured as a 15-year unsecured note with a fixed 15% annual interest rate.
- The promissory note prohibited any prepayment of principal or interest, requiring a single balloon payment of all principal and accumulated interest ($459,491) at the end of the 15-year term.
- Cecil Graegin's son, Paul Graegin, was a co-executor of the estate, a primary beneficiary, and the president of both the lending and parent corporations.
Procedural Posture:
- The Estate of Cecil Graegin filed a federal estate tax return claiming a $459,491 deduction for a future interest payment on a loan.
- The Commissioner of Internal Revenue disallowed the deduction and issued a notice of deficiency for $696,325.42.
- The Estate of Cecil Graegin, as petitioner, challenged the deficiency by filing a petition in the United States Tax Court.
Premium Content
Subscribe to Lexplug to view the complete brief
You're viewing a preview with Rule of Law, Facts, and Procedural Posture
Issue:
Is the full, non-prepayable, lump-sum interest payment on a 15-year loan, taken by an estate from a closely-held corporation to pay federal estate taxes, deductible as an administration expense under I.R.C. § 2053(a)(2)?
Opinions:
Majority - Jacobs
Yes, the full interest payment is a deductible administration expense. The court held that where a loan is necessary to preserve estate assets and its terms fix the total amount of interest with certainty, the entire amount is deductible even if it is not paid for many years. The court found that the loan was a genuine and necessary transaction to avoid a forced sale of the estate's illiquid stock, which is a valid purpose for an administration expense. Despite the close relationship between the borrower (the estate) and the lender (a corporation controlled by an estate beneficiary), the court found the transaction to be a bona fide loan, crediting the executor's testimony of his intent to repay. Crucially, because the note prohibited prepayment and had a fixed interest rate, the total amount of interest due at maturity was 'ascertainable with reasonable certainty' and not speculative, satisfying the requirements of Treasury regulations. The court concluded it was also reasonably certain that the interest would be paid.
Analysis:
This case established the legitimacy of the 'Graegin loan,' a significant estate planning technique for illiquid estates. The decision allows an estate to take a substantial, immediate estate tax deduction for the entire amount of interest on a loan, even though the interest will not be paid for many years. This provides immediate tax savings and helps preserve family-owned businesses or other illiquid assets that would otherwise have to be sold to pay taxes. The key precedent set is that an interest expense can be 'ascertainable with reasonable certainty' if the loan terms, particularly a prohibition on prepayment, make the total interest mathematically fixed and non-contingent.
