Douglas Brown v. Robert D. Fluharty
2013 WL 5047376, 748 S.E.2d 809, 231 W. Va. 613 (2013)
Premium Feature
Subscribe to Lexplug to listen to the Case Podcast.
Rule of Law:
Under West Virginia law, a non-holographic will is invalid if it lacks any form of signature by the testator or by someone signing in the testator's presence and at their direction. The doctrine of substantial compliance cannot excuse a complete failure to meet the statutory signature requirement.
Facts:
- On October 28, 2009, Bright McCausland executed a formal Last Will and Testament, naming Robert D. Fluharty as executor.
- Approximately six months later, McCausland was physically incapacitated and residing in a nursing care facility.
- On April 10th and 11th, 2010, McCausland allegedly dictated the terms of a new will to his nephew, Douglas Brown.
- Brown transcribed the dictation into a typewritten document entitled "Bright McCausland-Last Will."
- McCausland did not sign, make a mark on, or have another person sign the typewritten document on his behalf.
- Two of McCausland's healthcare providers signed the document, later attesting in affidavits that they witnessed McCausland stating the document contained his final desires.
- Bright McCausland died on April 22, 2010.
Procedural Posture:
- On May 20, 2010, Bright McCausland's original 2009 will was probated and recorded in Mason County, West Virginia.
- On July 14, 2011, petitioners filed a civil action in the circuit court seeking to revoke the original will and have the second, unsigned will admitted to probate.
- The respondent, Robert D. Fluharty, filed an answer and a motion for judgment on the pleadings, arguing the second will was invalid due to the lack of a signature.
- The circuit court (the court of first instance) granted the respondent's motion, concluding that the unsigned document was not a valid will.
- The petitioners (appellants) appealed the circuit court's order to the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia.
Premium Content
Subscribe to Lexplug to view the complete brief
You're viewing a preview with Rule of Law, Facts, and Procedural Posture
Issue:
Under West Virginia Code § 41-1-3, is a non-holographic will valid if it is not signed by the testator, nor by any other person in his presence and by his direction, even if two witnesses attest that the document contains the testator's final desires?
Opinions:
Majority - Per Curiam
No, a non-holographic will is not valid if it lacks any signature by the testator or a proxy. While West Virginia courts have applied a doctrine of substantial compliance to forgive minor deviations from statutory will formalities, that doctrine cannot cure a complete absence of a signature. The court reasoned that West Virginia Code § 41-1-3 unambiguously requires a will to be 'signed by the testator, or by some other person in his presence and by his direction.' This signature, whether a full name, initials, a mark, or a guided hand, serves as the critical indication of final testamentary intent. Without any signature whatsoever, there is no compliance to substantially comply with. To validate a document with no signature would be to disregard the plain language and protective purpose of the statute, which the court is not at liberty to do.
Analysis:
This case establishes a firm boundary for the application of the substantial compliance doctrine in the context of will execution. By refusing to extend the doctrine to a complete failure to sign, the court creates a bright-line rule that a will must contain some form of signature or mark from the testator to be valid. This decision reinforces the primacy of statutory formalities intended to prevent fraud and ensure finality in testamentary dispositions. The ruling signals that courts will not validate a purported will based solely on extrinsic evidence of intent when a core statutory requirement, like a signature, is entirely absent, thereby prioritizing the legislative mandate over the alleged intentions of the decedent in such circumstances.
Unlock the full brief for Douglas Brown v. Robert D. Fluharty