Delaney v. Reynolds
2005 Mass. App. LEXIS 361, 63 Mass. App. Ct. 239, 825 N.E. 2d 554 (2005)
Premium Feature
Subscribe to Lexplug to listen to the Case Podcast.
Rule of Law:
An individual's intentional act of self-harm is not, as a matter of law, a superseding cause that absolves a negligent defendant of liability if the self-harm was a reasonably foreseeable consequence of the defendant's negligence.
Facts:
- In July 1998, Kathleen Delaney began living with John M. Reynolds, a police officer.
- Reynolds was aware that Delaney was receiving active treatment for depression and substance abuse.
- Reynolds regularly stored his loaded, unlocked handgun in a duffle bag or bureau drawer in his bedroom, and knew that Delaney was aware of its location.
- In the month prior to the incident, Delaney's depression worsened, and she alleged she told Reynolds she wanted to end her life, to which he allegedly responded by handing her his gun.
- On the night of May 7, 1999, Delaney used crack cocaine and consumed alcohol.
- Upon her return home, Reynolds confronted Delaney about her substance abuse, they argued, and he ordered her to move out.
- While packing her belongings, Delaney took Reynolds's handgun from his duffle bag, went to the staircase, aimed at a window, and pulled the trigger twice; the gun did not fire.
- Delaney ran back to the bedroom with Reynolds in pursuit, put the gun under her chin, and pulled the trigger, inflicting a serious gunshot wound on herself.
Procedural Posture:
- Kathleen Delaney filed a negligence action against John M. Reynolds in the trial court.
- Reynolds moved for summary judgment.
- The trial court judge granted summary judgment in favor of Reynolds, ruling that Delaney's act was an intervening and superseding cause of her injury.
- Delaney, as appellant, appealed the summary judgment to the Massachusetts Appeals Court.
Premium Content
Subscribe to Lexplug to view the complete brief
You're viewing a preview with Rule of Law, Facts, and Procedural Posture
Issue:
Does a person's intentional act of self-harm with a firearm necessarily constitute a superseding cause that, as a matter of law, relieves the gun owner of liability for negligently storing the firearm?
Opinions:
Majority - Perretta, J.
No. A person's intentional act of self-harm does not automatically break the causal chain as a superseding cause; liability may still attach if the defendant's negligence created a foreseeable risk of that harm. The court reversed the summary judgment, reasoning that key material facts were in dispute. First, Delaney's state of mind—whether she intended to injure herself or believed the gun was unloaded—is a question of fact for a jury, and summary judgment is inappropriate for issues of intent. Second, even if Delaney did intend to harm herself, a jury could find that this action was a foreseeable result of Reynolds's negligence. Given Reynolds's knowledge of Delaney’s depression, substance abuse, and alleged suicidal ideations, his act of leaving a loaded, unlocked handgun accessible to her could be found to be the proximate cause of her injuries. The court concluded that the traditional rule treating suicide as a superseding cause is not absolute and that the modern analysis hinges on foreseeability, which is a question for the jury.
Analysis:
This decision marks a significant shift from the traditional, more rigid rule that treated suicide as a superseding cause breaking the chain of legal causation. By applying general principles of negligence and foreseeability to a case of self-harm, the court allows for greater potential liability for defendants who create risks for foreseeably vulnerable individuals. This ruling makes it more difficult for defendants to obtain summary judgment in similar cases, pushing the ultimate determination of proximate cause and foreseeability to the jury. It underscores a legal trend toward imposing a duty to protect others from self-harm when a defendant's affirmative negligence provides the means and the risk of such harm is foreseeable.
Unlock the full brief for Delaney v. Reynolds