City of Laredo, Texas v. Laredo Merchants Association
550 S.W.3d 586 (2018)
Premium Feature
Subscribe to Lexplug to listen to the Case Podcast.
Rule of Law:
A state law that expressly limits local government authority will preempt a municipal ordinance if the ordinance falls within the ambit of the statute's plain language. Under the Texas Solid Waste Disposal Act, a city ordinance banning single-use bags is preempted because the bags are 'containers,' the ordinance's purpose is for 'solid waste management,' and the ban is a 'manner' of regulation not specifically authorized by state law.
Facts:
- The City of Laredo, as part of a strategic plan to create a 'trash-free' city, adopted an ordinance.
- The ordinance made it unlawful for any commercial establishment to provide or sell certain single-use plastic or paper bags, defined as 'checkout bags,' to its customers.
- The stated purposes of the ordinance were to prevent litter, reduce costs associated with trash control and sewer maintenance, and protect against flooding caused by clogged drainage systems.
- A violation of the ordinance was a Class C misdemeanor, punishable by a fine of up to $2,000 per violation.
Procedural Posture:
- The Laredo Merchants Association sued the City of Laredo in a state trial court, seeking declaratory and injunctive relief to prevent enforcement of the ordinance.
- Both parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment.
- The trial court granted the City's motion for summary judgment and denied the Merchants' motion, upholding the ordinance.
- The Laredo Merchants Association, as appellant, appealed the trial court's decision to the state's intermediate court of appeals.
- A divided court of appeals reversed the trial court's judgment, rendering judgment for the Merchants and declaring that the Act preempts the ordinance.
- The City of Laredo, as petitioner, sought and was granted a petition for review by the Supreme Court of Texas, the state's highest court for civil matters.
Premium Content
Subscribe to Lexplug to view the complete brief
You're viewing a preview with Rule of Law, Facts, and Procedural Posture
Issue:
Does the Texas Solid Waste Disposal Act, which prohibits local governments from restricting the sale or use of a 'container or package' for 'solid waste management purposes' in a manner not authorized by state law, preempt a city ordinance banning commercial establishments from providing single-use plastic and paper bags to customers?
Opinions:
Majority - Chief Justice Hecht
Yes. The Texas Solid Waste Disposal Act preempts the City of Laredo's ordinance. The court's reasoning is based on a three-part analysis of the Act's preemption provision. First, the ordinance was enacted for 'solid waste management purposes,' as its stated goals of reducing litter and trash align with the Act's definition of 'management,' which includes controlling the 'generation' of solid waste. Second, a single-use plastic or paper bag falls within the ordinary, plain meaning of a 'container' or 'package' as used in the Act. Third, the ordinance's outright ban is a 'manner' of regulation, and the City failed to identify any state law that specifically authorizes this manner of regulation; general grants of municipal authority over water systems or sanitation are insufficient to overcome the Act's specific preemption.
Concurring - Justice Guzman
Yes. The court correctly interpreted the plain language of the statute, which clearly expresses the Legislature's intent to preempt local ordinances like Laredo's. Although the court is bound to enforce the statute as written, the concurrence is written to highlight the urgent and grave environmental and economic consequences of plastic bag pollution on wildlife, livestock, and key Texas industries. The opinion urges the Texas Legislature, which holds the constitutional authority to make such policy decisions, to take direct action to address the problem or to amend the law to create a specific exception for local control.
Analysis:
This decision significantly impacts the ability of home-rule cities in Texas to enact local environmental regulations, particularly concerning single-use products. By holding that the Texas Solid Waste Disposal Act preempts local bag bans, the court established a precedent that centralizes regulatory authority over such matters at the state level. The ruling effectively invalidated similar ordinances in other Texas cities and requires that any future local attempts to regulate containers for waste management purposes be explicitly authorized by the state legislature. This reinforces the principle that even the broad self-governance powers of home-rule cities are subordinate to clear, express limitations imposed by state law.
Unlock the full brief for City of Laredo, Texas v. Laredo Merchants Association