Chambers v. Bringenberg
309 Neb. 888 (2021)
Premium Feature
Subscribe to Lexplug to listen to the Case Podcast.
Rule of Law:
A Transfer-on-Death (TOD) deed is not a "conveyance" or "encumbrance" under Nebraska's homestead statute, Neb. Rev. Stat. § 40-104. Therefore, a TOD deed transferring an interest in a homestead property is valid even without the signature and acknowledgment of the transferor's spouse.
Facts:
- David Chambers and Eleanor Chambers married in 1995.
- In early 2017, due to deteriorating health, David moved into an assisted living facility.
- In June 2017, Eleanor purchased a house (the Meadows house) solely in her own name and resided there until her death.
- David never resided in the Meadows house and stated he never intended to do so.
- On February 8, 2018, Eleanor executed and recorded a TOD deed for the Meadows house, naming her daughter, Angie Bringenberg, as the designated beneficiary.
- David did not execute or acknowledge the TOD deed.
- Eleanor died on March 3, 2018.
Procedural Posture:
- David Chambers initiated an action to quiet title against Angie Bringenberg in the District Court for Lancaster County.
- Bringenberg filed an answer and a counterclaim for slander of title.
- David moved for partial summary judgment, asserting the TOD deed was void for lacking his signature as required by homestead law.
- The district court granted David's motion for partial summary judgment, finding the TOD deed void and quieting title in Eleanor's estate.
- The district court subsequently dismissed Bringenberg's counterclaim as moot, rendering the judgment final.
- Bringenberg, as appellant, appealed the final judgment, and the Nebraska Supreme Court granted her petition to bypass the intermediate appellate court.
Premium Content
Subscribe to Lexplug to view the complete brief
You're viewing a preview with Rule of Law, Facts, and Procedural Posture
Issue:
Does Nebraska's homestead statute, Neb. Rev. Stat. § 40-104, which requires an instrument conveying or encumbering a homestead to be executed by both spouses, apply to a Transfer-on-Death (TOD) deed?
Opinions:
Majority - Justice Freudenberg
No. A Transfer-on-Death (TOD) deed is not subject to the spousal execution and acknowledgment requirements of the homestead statute, Neb. Rev. Stat. § 40-104. The court reasoned that a TOD deed is fundamentally different from the inter vivos 'conveyances' and 'encumbrances' contemplated by the homestead statute. Under the Nebraska Uniform Real Property Transfer on Death Act (TODA), a TOD deed is a nonprobate will substitute that has no effect until the transferor's death; it is fully revocable and does not create any present legal or equitable interest in the beneficiary during the transferor's lifetime. Because the instrument operates as a devise upon death rather than a conveyance during life, it does not threaten the family's right to occupancy, which is the core protection of the homestead law. The court analogized a TOD deed to a traditional will, which has never required a spouse's signature to be valid, and noted that the Legislature, presumed to know of the homestead statutes, did not include a spousal consent requirement when enacting the TODA.
Analysis:
This decision provides critical clarity on the interplay between modern estate planning tools and traditional property law protections in Nebraska. It firmly establishes that TOD deeds are treated as testamentary instruments, akin to wills, rather than inter vivos conveyances for the purposes of homestead law. This holding strengthens the utility of TOD deeds as an efficient nonprobate transfer mechanism, allowing property owners to devise their interests without the consent of a non-owner spouse. The ruling directs that a surviving spouse's remedies regarding such a transfer are not to void the deed itself but lie within probate concepts like claims for an elective share or statutory allowances against the decedent's augmented estate.
